By W. Terry Whalin @terrywhalin
Do you have book reviews for your book? Are they “honest” reviews or something you have orchestrated from friends and family? It is hard work to write a good book and get it into the market. Whether you work with a traditional publisher or self-publish, I hope you have produced an excellent product. At some point in the process, you are ready to release this book to the market. What will others say about your writing? The natural tendency is to expect everyone to glow about your book and send you accolades.
Yet that expectation is not reality. Not every review will receive five stars. These reviews are important social proof from readers and feedback to you as the author. Several years ago, I met a novelist who claimed to have sold thousands of books on Amazon. Yes, this author touted amazing numbers for her book sales. Yet when I looked on Amazon, there was one review—and the author had written that review. If you don’t think this result is unusual, take a few minutes and look at any bestselling novel on Amazon. If the book has been selling well, then people enjoy it and write reviews—often hundreds of reviews.
I look at other books (even self-published) which have less than five reviews—even if they have been out on the market for several years. Again, this absence is social proof of the quality and feedback from readers. Your book should have reviews and as the author, you need to take responsibility to get these reviews.
As the author, you can create a launch team. Recently I’ve been involved in the launch of several books. I’ve filled out applications to be a part of the launch team. These applications ask why I should be included. The launch director creates a private Facebook area with encouragement to read the book and post reviews. Recently I got added to a launch team that said they were only going to let 500 people be on their launch team. What a huge team but see the social proof these authors are gathering for the launch of their book?
Your team may be smaller than 500. Can you launch your book with 25 reviews on Amazon? To launch with 25 reviews, you will need to gather at least 50 people who agree to review your book and will post a review during the week your book is launched. Why so many more than the 25 you need? Even though you do your work, and the person has committed, not everyone carries through with their commitment. Maybe the book doesn’t reach them in the mail. Maybe they got ill. Maybe they have some family emergency. Life happens for every person, and they don’t carry through with their promised review. As the author, you need to recognize this fact and move beyond it with even more people to write the review.
This process of organizing and getting reviews takes work and effort from the author. So I encourage you to get this free teleseminar that I created with Dana Lynn Smith about reviews: http://yourbookreviewed.com/
In your request to the reviewer, you are asking for an “honest” review. Not every review will be a Five Star Amazon review or glowing. A while back, one of my Morgan James authors called me almost in tears asking what she should do with a one-star review. My advice: do nothing. Don’t comment back. Don’t complain to Amazon. Do nothing. The fact that you’ve received a variety of reviews is good for your book. In fact, the one- or two-star reviews validate the four and five star reviews you have received. The low reviews show others your reviews are from real readers.
Over ten years ago as a frustrated acquisitions editor, I wrote Book Proposals That Sell. The book has hundreds of Five Star Amazon reviews, and it has helped many people. It continues to be reviewed. Several years ago, I received a detailed One Star review. Did I read the review? Yes. Did I take any action or reach out to this reviewer? No. This book continues to help people. You need to fix what you can, then let the rest go—and continue working on getting reviews.
I encourage you to set personal goals for the number of reviews. For example, when your book has 50 reviews on Amazon, then Amazon takes notice and behind-the-scenes will begin to implement some additional marketing for your book. This increase will also happen when you reach 100 and 150 reviews. Even if your book has been published for years, keep asking people and encouraging others to write reviews. I also encourage you to become active in the publishing community and write reviews for the books that you read, then others will be eager to help you with your book. It’s an important aspect of your work as an author.
W. Terry Whalin, a writer and acquisitions editor lives in California. A former magazine editor and former literary agent, Terry is an acquisitions editor at Morgan James Publishing. He has written more than 60 nonfiction books including Jumpstart Your Publishing Dreams and Billy Graham. Get Terry’s newest book, 10 Publishing Myths for only $10, free shipping and bonuses worth over $200. To help writers catch the attention of editors and agents, Terry wrote his bestselling Book Proposals That $ell, 21 Secrets To Speed Your Success. Check out his free Ebook, Platform Building Ideas for Every Author. His website is located at: www.terrywhalin.com
The Conversation
Book reviews really are important! But most people don’t know how to write them. I have a short description on my website that tells people how to do it, along with a link to a website that gives more detail.
It’s so frustrating when I read one or two star “reviews” that lament a damaged cover. That is NOT a book review! Why does Amazon even allow that? They clearly check out reviews because I’ve been blocked from reviewing a couple of books because I’m “friends” with the author on social media.
Sigh.
Pam,
I hear and understand your frustration with getting people to write reviews and also the fact each site–particularly the large one–has their own “rules” and expectations. It takes a bit of persistence sometimes to get these reviews to show up–even on my part. I’ve written over 1,000 reviews on Amazon and about 900 reviews on Goodreads as well as on other websites like Barnes and Noble.com.
To help write the review, I recommend this relatively inexpensive tool from my friend Sandra Beckwith. There is one for fiction and one for nonfiction. When you buy them, you have the rights to use them and give them away: https://buildbookbuzz.com/reader-book-review-form/ If people see a template with a series of questions, they get an idea how to write the review. I know not everyone will do it but at least you’ve given them some help to write the review.
Persistence and consistency are key and I hope this helps you and others,
Terry
But Terry, how does a writer come up with 500 readers for a launch team? Or even 50? Is there some trick to that? Most authors don’t have that many friends they can ask. So what are the secrets to finding people willing to do a book review?